The Best Pizza in Fort Collins, According to Locals

Hey FoCo foodies, this one’s for you! 🍽️

When it comes to finding the best pizza in Fort Collins, opinions run deep! From classic New York-style slices to deep-dish favorites, the community has voted, and the results are in. Whether you’re looking for a late-night slice, a cozy sit-down experience, or a go-to delivery option, these are the top pizza joints that locals can’t stop raving about. 🍕✨

🍕 The Best Pizza in Fort Collins, According to Locals

Everyone has their go-to pizza spot, but which ones stand out as the best in Fort Collins? We took a deep dive into local recommendations, and these are the places that got the most love. Whether you like crispy thin crust, gooey deep dish, or creative toppings, there’s a slice for everyone!

🏆 The Top Picks

🥇 Krazy Karl’s (8 Votes)

If there’s one pizza joint that Fort Collins locals rally behind, it’s Krazy Karl’s. Famous for their unique topping combos and cream cheese-stuffed crusts, this spot is a must-try. Whether you’re getting delivery or dining in, be prepared—this place gets busy for a reason!

🥈 Pulcinella Pizzeria (6 Votes)

For those who prefer authentic Italian-style pizza, Pulcinella is the place to go. With a perfect balance of crispy crust, fresh toppings, and house-made sauce, it’s a favorite for classic pizza lovers.

🥉 Pizza Casbah (6 Votes)

If you’re looking for massive slices and a classic New York-style experience, Pizza Casbah is the answer. Their Park Avenue pizza was a frequent favorite among locals.

🔥 More Local Favorites

🍕 Panhandlers (5 Votes) – Fort Collins’ deep-dish king! If you’re craving a thick, cheesy, Chicago-style pizza, Panhandlers is the place to go.

🍕 JJ’s Wood-Fired Pizza (3 Votes) – Authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, baked in a wood-fired oven imported from Italy. A hidden gem for pizza purists.

🍕 Slyce (3 Votes) – If you love creative toppings, Slyce delivers. From mac & cheese pizza to unique flavor combos, it’s a fun spot for adventurous eaters.

🍕 Surfside 7 (3 Votes) – A bar that serves pizza as big as your head. Locals love this spot for late-night slices and a lively atmosphere.

🗓 What’s Happenin’ in Fort Collins: Event Listings

🌤 Fort Collins Weather Outlook

Monday, March 25 – ☀️ Mostly Sunny | High: 72°F | Low: 44°F | Wind: WNW 19 mph | 0% chance of rain

Tuesday, March 26 – ☀️ Mostly Sunny | High: 70°F | Low: 38°F | Wind: SW 10 mph | 1% chance of rain

Wednesday, March 27 – ☀️ Sunny | High: 76°F | Low: 44°F | Wind: S 8 mph | 2% chance of rain

Thursday, March 28 – ⛅ Partly Cloudy | High: 82°F | Low: 46°F | Wind: WSW 10 mph | 9% chance of rain

💡 Weather Tip: We’re in for a warm and sunny stretch this week! With highs reaching the 80s by Thursday, it’s the perfect time to hit a brewery patio or take a scenic hike. Don’t forget the sunscreen! ☀️🍻🏞️

🍕 What’s Your Favorite?

Interested in other What’s Happenin’ newsletters?